Skip Navigation
Falvey Library
You are exploring: Home > Blogs

Cat in the Stax: Are you Team Wheels or Team Doors?

By Ethan Shea

"Monster's Inc. Door Factory"

Forget the “The dress” and the controversy over “Laurel” and “Yanny.” The next big internet debate is here!

This time everyone is arguing over whether there are more doors or wheels in the world, and the lighthearted yet passionate banter is certainly welcome.

Those on Team Wheels often cite the immense number of wheeled vehicles in the world. In addition to cars, there are skateboards, scooters, and bicycles. Moreover, you need to replace these wheels more often than you need to replace most doors, so there must be a lot of them!

However, members of Team Doors point to skyscrapers, bathroom stalls, refrigerator doors, and even kitchen cabinets. Regardless of what side of the debate you’re on, both doors and wheels have some tempting points.

One of the most interesting aspects of this debate is the fact that many people are struggling to define what counts as a door and what counts as a wheel. Should cabinets count as doors? What about mini wheels pasta? Is each individual morsel technically a wheel?

"NovaRacing Race Car"

NovaRacing Car in Falvey Library

While I have my own opinions on these controversies, the main reason why this debate is so fascinating is because it is surprisingly philosophical. In fact, the struggle to define doors and wheels remind me of Plato’s Theory of Forms.

We all have abstract ideas of what wheels and doors are, and this non-physical concept is the truest, most essential form of them. When we try to translate our general ideas of the forms to specific objects, things can get complicated. If you’d like to read more about this idea and consider how it applies to the great door and wheel debate, Plato discusses it a bit in The Republic, which is available here at Falvey, among several other dialogues.

There are many more reasons why this debate has a home in the Library. First of all, Falvey recently acquired a new set of wheels, as a NovaRacing car was just relocated to outside of the Idea Lab due to the CEER Expansion Project. To learn more about the car and NovaRacing, check out this blog.

"Narnia Wardrobe Door"

Wardrobe door to Narnia

There are also countless famous doors in literature and film. In addition to the image from Monster’s Inc. featured above, a few that come to mind are the Doors of Durin from The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers, the entrance to Platform 9 3/4 from the Harry Potter series, and the wardrobe door to Narnia from The Chronicles of Narnia.

However, we can’t forget famous sets of wheels such as The Magic School Bus, Herbie from The Love Bug, and Lightning McQueen from Cars!

I’m curious where everyone stands on this hot topic, so don’t be afraid to leave a comment taking a side. Are you Team Wheels or Team Doors?


Headshot of Ethan SheaEthan Shea is a first-year English Graduate Student and Graduate Assistant at Falvey Memorial Library


‘Cat in the Stax: Celebrating with the Hobbits

By Jenna Newman


History of Hobbit Day

Sept. 22 is a big day in the Villanova community from 1842 Day to Voter Registration Day. However, another arguably important holiday on the same day is Hobbit Day. Hobbit Day takes place on the day of Bilbo and Frodo Baggins shared birthday, the date of the Long Awaited Party. 

The American Tolkien Society first proclaimed Hobbit Day in 1978. They refer to it as essentially the ideal holiday, combining the costumes of Halloween, food of thanksgiving, gifts of Christmas, picnic atmosphere of Labor Day and Memorial Day, and the fireworks of the Fourth of July. You can also celebrate by diving into the literary world of Tolkien and Middle Earth.

What to read? 

The great thing about The Lord of the Rings is that the ideas from the trilogy and the world that J.R.R. Tolkien created can be examined in conjunction with many of the subjects we study today including philosophy, history, religion, and international relations. Below is a list of books in Falvey’s collection that have Hobbit ties to a variety of disciplines. 

The Hobbit, or There and Back Again

In compiling a list about books to read for Hobbit Day, it would be ridiculous to have anything other than the book where it all started at the top of list. For adventure lovers or Lord of the Rings newbies, The Hobbit is the place to start. Before taking a deep dive into some of the theories at work behind the story, it is imperative to answer the two questions of, “Who are Hobbits?” and “What is the world they live in?”

The Hobbit Party: The Vision of Freedom That Tolkien Got and the West Forgot 

This book combines the world of Middle Earth with the politics of today. Providing a critical look at Tolkien’s political beliefs of small government and economic freedom, authors Jay W. Richards and Jonathan Witt examine how these beliefs can be seen within the storylines of the Shire. It can be argued that the political message of The Lord of the Rings series is second only to its  religious message. 

A Hobbit, a Wardrobe, and a Great War: How J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis Rediscovered Faith, Friendship, and Heroism in the Cataclysm of 1914-1918

If you have any interest in history, biographies or the faith that became the basis for The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings, and The Chronicles of Narnia, this is the book to grab off of the shelves. This book explores how the Great War led to a friendship between authors J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis as well as the foundations for what we now know as the worlds of Narnia and Middle Earth. 

The Lord of the Rings: Popular Culture in Global Context

Ernest Mathijs appeals to readers interested in the fields of media and film studies as he examines the impact of The Lord of the Rings on both the regional and global industries. Throughout the chapters the impact of the franchise, reception by critics and fans, and the success of spin-offs are all discussed. This book offers yet another perspective on the wide-spreading impact of the franchise.

The Philosophy of Tolkien: The Worldview Behind the Lord of the Rings

For anyone either well-versed or just interested in philosophy, this book looks at 50 philosophical questions in 13 categories and then examines Tolkien’s work to answer each question. Author Peter Kreeft relies on Tolkien’s texts to answer each question, providing a strong framework of analysis. The deep-dive into the philosophical world of Middle Earth is an adventure separate from the literary works themselves.

The International Relations of Middle-Earth: Learning from the Lord of the Rings

Based on a course taught at the University of Southern California, this book examines how the world of Middle Earth can help us learn about our own world. Many of the common themes in international relations such as good versus evil and human agency versus determinism are explored in Tolkien’s works. 


Jenna Newman is a graduate assistant in Falvey Memorial Library and a graduate student in the Communication Department. Current mood: Planning my next Lord of the Rings movie night. 




1 People Like This Post


Last Modified: September 16, 2020